The Amish Creamery Co. at 200 150th Ave. was born to fulfill a dream. I wanted a Amish store in Florida. Our roots are from Amish country. The Amish Creamer is shocked with elderberry jam, biscuit mix and rolled butter, along with home-style ice cream made the Amish way. Everything in our store is Amish, with the exception of some soft drinks and crackers.

We have a great location On Madeira Beach.  The previous tenant was a bikini shop, but the building was originally a gas station, so it required a face lift and tender loving care to transform it into this Amish style delight. The end result was worth it. The big Amish face on the sign had passers-by intrigued. Customers are coming in and saying, 'We're glad to see you open now. Many come in for ice cream, and are unaware of the Amish brand meats and cheeses, Amish Wedding preserves, candy, dry goods and other Amish products offered at the shop. Once they're inside the store, they stay and browse.

I love our products, and all our customers (so far) have raved over everything from the trash can ice cream to the dandelion jelly to kluski  noodles.

If you have never stopped in to The Amish Creamery as yet, then you are in for a nice treat. I personally would like to invite you to check us out and see for yourself. 

See you soon Clint Herlein (owner)